top of page

FCI-style written critiques! 

at the Bluegrass Cluster, Lexington, KY

Labor Day weekend, Sept 1-3!

Have you ever wondered what a top  European judge would say about your dog? Here's your chance to get a written commentary of the virtues of your dog -along with an honest evaluation of any faults. The evaluations are confidential. If you choose to share them, that's up to you. 

Mr. Christian Janes is an FCI judge of over 40 breeds. He will provide these written commentaries on the breeds he judges and, if desired, on breeds he is not yet licensed for. (If he is not a judge for your breed, feel free to ask. If he's not comfortable in that breed, he'll let us know.) Dogs and puppies of all ages are eligible and will be evaluated with respect to their age.
​
List of breeds:
Mr. Janes has owned/bred:

Pyrenean Shepherd, Berger Picard, Pomeranian, Finnish Lapphund, Whippet, Tibetan Terrier, American Akita, Beauceron

Breeds judged in AKC Herding group: 

Beauceron 

Bergamasco 

Berger Picard 

Bouvier des Flandres 

Briard 

Finnish Lapphund 

Icelandic Sheepdog 

Polish Lowland Sheepdog 

Pumi 

Pyrenean Shepherd

​

Breeds judged in AKC Working group: 

Anatolian Shepherd  

Great Pyrenees 

Komondor 

Kuvasz 

Tibetan Mastiff 

Saint Bernard

​

Breeds judged in AKC Toy group: 

Pomeranian

​

Breeds judged in AKC Non sporting group: 

Finnish Spitz 

French Bulldog

​

Breeds judged in AKC Miscellaneous or FSS:

Caucasian Shepherd

Central Asian Shepherd Dog

German Spitz

Mudi

Slovensky Cuvac 

Shapendoes

Pyrenean Mastiff

Estrela Mountain Dog

Tornjak

Additional Herding Breeds judged in FCI group 1: 

Bouvier des Ardennes 

Maremmano-Abruzzese (Maremma)

Polski Owczarek Podhalanski (Tatra Mountain Dog) 

Slovensky Cuvac 

Gos d'Atura (Catalonian Sheepdog)

Shapendoes (Dutch Sheepdog)

Cao da Serra de Aires 

Ciobanesc Romanesc Carpatin (Carpathian Mtn Dog)

Ciobanesc Romanesc Mioritic (Romanian Mioritic Shepherd)

South Russian Oftscharka 

Mudi

​

Additional Working Breeds judged in FCI group 2:

Caucasian Oftscharka 

Central Asian 

Oftscharka Sarplaninac (Charplaninatz) 

Krasky Ovcar 

Mastin de los Pirineos (Pyrenean Mastiff)

Cao da Serra da Estrela ​(Estrela Mountain Dog)

Aidi 

Tornjak (Croatian Shepherd)

Ciobanesc Romanesc Bucovina

​

Additional Nordic Breeds judged in FCI group 5: 

German Spitz 

Lapinporokoira (Lapp Reindeer dog)

Japanese Spitz  

Volpino Italiano (Florentine Spitz)

How Does it Work?
Exam

Your dog will be examined and moved as in the show ring, but the judge will take a bit more time and will maintain a running commentary in English comparing your dog to its breed standard. This will be written down, either by the judge or by a confidential secretary. After the judge has finished his initial commentary, you may feel free to ask questions.

​

Ratings

Your dog will also receive a rating, which will be marked down as part of the written critique. It's like an overall grade. There are 5 ratings: Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair and Insufficient.

Our program will roughly follow FCI policies but with a few adjustments to increase confidentiality and streamline the process. No ribbons or colored cards will be given publicly for the various grades. Instead, each dog examined will be given an envelop containing a copy of the evaluation with the rating marked on the same page. If the dog receives an Excellent rating, a ribbon marked Excellent will be discretely placed in the envelop as well.

 

If you desire, all dogs rated Excellent are eligible to return at the end of the day to publicly compete for Best of the Day. This is not an FCI element, but one we add for its educational value and just for fun. It will be held a half hour after the finish of BIS judging of the AKC show that day. This part is not confidential. If you choose to compete, the judge's comparisons will be made out loud to the assembled audience. Best of the Day in breed will be given in each breed and those winners are then eligible to compete for Best of the Day all breed. Ribbons will be awarded dogs the judge may designate as "Excellent Plus", and to Best of the Day in breed and Best of the Day all breed. There will be an opportunity for you to take informal pictures with the judge. 


EXCELLENT may be awarded only to a dog that is very close to the ideal standard of the breed, is presented in excellent condition, displays a correct temperament, and has excellent structure. Superior breed type outweighs more generic imperfections. 

VERY GOOD may be awarded only to a dog that possesses the typical features of its breed and is in correct condition. A few minor faults may be tolerated.

GOOD is awarded to a dog that displays the main features of its breed, but also has some clear faults.

FAIR is awarded to a dog that corresponds adequately to its breed without possessing all the generally accepted type features, or whose physical condition leaves something to be desired.

INSUFFICIENT must be awarded to a dog that does not correspond to the type required by the standard; displays behaviour clearly not in line with its standard or is overly aggressive; has testicular abnormalities; has dental flaw(s) or a jaw abnormality; shows a color or coat imperfection; does not appear healthy, or has some disqualifying fault(s).

Dogs that cannot be awarded any one of the qualifications mentioned above should be released from the ring with:

CANNOT BE JUDGED  – This rating is given to a dog whose gait and movement cannot be assessed (dog does not move, constantly jumps up and down around its handler or tries to get out of the ring); constantly avoids the judge so that its bite, teeth, anatomy, construction, tail or testicles cannot be examined; shows traces of operations or treatments that appear deceptive or lead the judge to suspect operations intended to correct some fault in the dog (e.g. eyelids, ears, tail). Dogs who cannot be judged will be given a few comments about overall type but the dog's behavior will necessarily limit the scope of such comments.

bottom of page